Migel 2009-06-17 21:29:45

I hope that now my english has improved slightly, that you can understand my story bit better.

Animators post their movies here to be seen to public on a website which allows the viewers ( peeps like me ) 2 watch them/rate them and review them.

But there are some animators who compare their skill to that of their reviewer in order to dispower any negative based review. The hypocrite part of this action would be of course embracing the postive reviewers who also have no skill. But im not even going into that behaviour.

Look all im saying is i am a engineer and you are an artist. I can say your animation sucks. This is just simple opinion from a receiver off your movie. Then you can choose whetever to look into it or just discard ( a bad review in my opinion is one that doesnt go into details why it sucked for him )...but ffs dont defend by comparing your own skill to that of the reviewer.

Same goes for me, if you see me build a robot free to walk in a amusement park carrieing kids and kids dont like it or even worse it isnt even a safe construction. Then you as the receiver of that information can tell me what exactly you dont like about my work and maybe Ill look into it if I find the reasoning behind it valid enough.

I am not going to stand there saying you couldnt do any better because that it is a given but you dont need to be a expert to say my construction is unsafe if you can clearly see that kids can get their fingers stuck in the machinery.

So if someone makes a well animated movie but uses slapstick humor for kids that I dont like then in my review I will praise his animating skills but will give a lower grade because of bad humor. It failed to amuse me... so lower grade.

Like in a restaurant when your stuck on the toillet for 20 minutes because of bad prepared meal, you dont want this asshole of a cook to say to you that you couldnt cook the meal any better if you come with a complaint.

If the guy said that his way of cooking only upsets the stomach for a small portion of the crowd and apologised for not warning me about it im actually good. Im already good without the apologisy since I can see now that he cooked that meal based on previous accomplishments.

Same goes for watching movies. If your movie that you showcase in front of my face causes me to spend a large portion of time with my head over the toilllet than the website allows me to review it. Either read it, dont read it. I dont care if you comment on its value or not.

But dont be an totall ass comaring your animating skill to that of mine.